Cross Compound Compressor Design IV
Nelson Riedel, Nelson@NelsonsLocomotive.com
10/14/2005, last updated
04/08/2006

We've covered the entire design expect for the valves in Parts I, II & III.  Can't put it off any longer --- time to do the valves.

The prototype uses piston valves with cast iron rings for both the main valve and the reversing valve. A whole bunch of rings are required and I wasn't excited about making the rings.  One alternative is to use slide valves but they have their own set of problems such as not sealing very well and it's difficult to get at the sealing surfaces.  Personal experience has shown that O-Rings work great on main pistons but I didn't think they would work on valve pistons where the side of the rings have to slide over the ports in the side of the cylinder.   I did a little research on this before starting the compressor design and found that O-Rings seem to hold up on valve pistons.  One possible reason is that the pressure in this application is much less than in many other O-Ring applications so the O-Ring  squeeze can be less.  The test results are at Using O-Rings on Piston Valves I also found one manufacturer that uses O-Rings on the valve piston of a steam powered pump.

O-Ring:  Initially I planned to use a #008 double seal Viton O-ring.  The  008 size has a nominal 5/16" OD and 1/16" cross section.  I build the  valve system using this O-Ring and was not happy with it.  At the very small sizes the double seal ring seems to be less robust than the regular O-Ring   I decided to increase the size to #10 (3/8"  nominal OD) to get a little more force to move the main valve and use the standard O-Ring shape.  The #010 has a  0.239" ID and a 0.070" cross section width.  The cylinder ID will be 3/8" = 0.375".    The piston will have a 3/32" wide groove and I'll start with a groove ID of 0.250" which will give a nominal squeeze of about 0.007".  The rings have some variation so the actual squeeze will likely be in the range 0.004" to 0.010".  This should give a good seal to well lubricated steam.  The seal might be too tight and make the main valve with five rings difficult to move.  If that is the case, I'll decrease the groove ID slightly.

Reversing Valve Assembly: The sketch at right shows the reversing valve assembly in the two extreme positions. The passages to the left represent the valve ports. The individual components are labeled on the right side.  The valve seals are a #006 (1/8" X 1/4" X 1/16") Viton O-Rings.   The valve movement between the extremes is 5/32".   The part of the ports which the O-Ring will slide over will be 0.040" diameter.  The piston diameter is 3/8"" less appropriate clearance.  The valve rod is 1/8" diameter.

Main Valve Assembly: The diagram above shows the main valve in the two extreme positions.  The piston has a ~3/8" OD and rides in a 3/8" ID - 9/16" OD sleeve.  The 9 ports are labeled with the destinations.  The piston moves 0.156" between the two extreme positions.

One of the challenges with the valve design is to figure out how to route the the steam from the ports to the destination indicated on the drawing.   Turns out that it isn't as bad as it looked initially.  

  • The two ports that go to the bottom of the steam cylinders will go straight down from the valve through the upper steam head and then through the filler strip between the cylinders to the bottom of the cylinders. 

  • The two ports that go to the top of the steam cylinders will go from the side of the valve cylinder through the upper steam head to the top of the cylinders.  

  • An exhaust channel runs from the port on the left side of the compressor across the top of the head  under the main valve to the reversing valve.  The main valve exhaust port will go down to this exhaust channel.  A small vertical passage will be drilled along side the reversing valve cylinder into the exhaust channel to provide exhaust to the top of the reversing valve.

  • The steam input goes from the port on the right side of the compressor then in a channel across the top of the head to the side of the valve housing and then up into the housing , around the reversing valve to the side of the main valve where it feeds the two main valve steam ports.  

  • The ports on each end that go to the reversing valve will route along the side of the main valve and intersect with holes that connect to the reversing valve housing.              

Another decision is the diameter of the steam passages.  I used 3/32" diameter passages on the single cylinder water pump on the shay.  It was capable of running much faster than desired when the supply valve was completely opened.   I decided to make the majority of the passages here  0.089" with any open ends plugged with 4-40 set screws.   The ends of the exhaust and steam input passages are  1/8" with the open ends plugged with 6-32 set screws.   

MRSR91Valves Photos: This and the next two photos show the valve on the top of the MRSR91  The cylinder on the right side holds the reversing valve.   Square piece running front to back holds the main valve.  Note that the end of the square piece is above the head.  The gap under the square piece allows access to the head bolt nuts.
The valve from a different angle.  The loop is for hoisting the compressor.
Another view of the valve.  Unfortunately I wasn't able to take a photo of the compressor from above.

Valve Assembly: The drawing on right identifies the parts which comprise the valve assembly.  Drawings for individual parts are below.   The individual parts are:
  • HM562-Upper Steam Cylinder Head
  • HM563 - Valve Housing
  • HM564 - Valve Reinforcement
  • HM565 - Reversing Valve Piston
  • HM566 - Reversing Valve Cover
  • HM567 - Main Valve Sleeve
  • HM568 - Main Valve Piston
  • HM569 - Main Valve End Covers
  • HM570 - Upper Steam Head Large Alignment Washer
  • HM570 - Upper Steam Head Small Alignment Washer
  • HM572 - Reversing Valve Rod.
Upper Steam Cylinder Head: The outside edge and attachment bolt pattern of the upper steam head is identical to that of the other three heads.  The upper steam head is different in that it is machined from  5/16" thick stock.   The 0.906" wide center section is 5/16" thick while the rest of the head is milled down to 1/8" thickness matching the other heads.  

The input & exhaust passages run through the thicker middle section, the exhaust on the left and the steam input on the right.

 

Upper Steam Head Passage Dimensions: The Upper Steam Head drawing is repeated on the right with the attachment holes removed so that the position of the passages can be dimensioned more clearly  The vertical holes on each end match up with  passages down the side of the cylinders to the steam input and exhaust ports.   The other vertical holes match up with mating holes in the valve housing which sets on the head. 
Valve Housing:    The valve housing is made from a 3/4" length of 2" diameter brass or bronze.   The sides are milled to the dimensions shown.  The 0.906" section lines up with the raised part of the upper steam head.  The vertical 3/8" diameter hole is the reversing valve cylinder.  The 9/16" horizontal hole will hold the main valve sleeve.   The 3/8" wide recess in the left side is for the Valve reinforcement.

Many additional holes are required for the valve passages.  These passages are shown in subsequent drawings.

 

Valve Reinforcement:  This piece reinforces the upper part of the compressor so that it can be hoisted by the eye.   This piece has no function on our model other than aesthetics.

Valve Housing & Reinforcement Attachment: The valve housing and reinforcement are each attached to the head with two 7/16" long #2-56 FH brass screws up through the head. The  drawing shows the approximate position of these screws. The exact position is not critical except the screws must miss the steam and exhaust passages that run side-to-side through the head and also miss the other steam passages that run through the valve housing.  The holes in the reinforcement and housing should be tapped about 3/16" deep.  

The housing and reinforcement will be silver soldered to the head.  These screws will hold everything together during the soldering process and also keep everything is position should the assembly be reheated later.  

     

Valve Output Passages: There are four valve output passages, one to each end of each steam cylinder.  The passages go down through the valve housing and through the head via 0.089" holes that are tapped 4-40 on the under side of the head.  (The threaded ends are plugged with setscrews  during testing of the valve system.)

The slots provide access from the passages to the top of the two steam cylinders.  The other two passages feed through mating holes in the steam cylinder unit (through the filler strip between the cylinders) to the bottom of the cylinder and then out through similar slots in the bottom of the cylinder unit to the bottom of the two steam cylinders.    

Valve Exhaust Passages: The drawing shows the exhaust passages.  The main exhaust passage runs across the head from the left side.   The left end of the passage is plugged with a 6-32 setscrew.  The passage connects to the exhaust port via a passage down the side of the cylinder.  The passage connects to the center of the main valve via the hole up through the head.  The lower end of that hole is plugged with a 4-40 setscrew.    The right end of the  horizontal passage opens into the area around the reversing valve stem and in turn to the bottom of the reversing valve cylinder.  The 1/16" vertical hole connects from the horizontal exhaust passage to the top of the reversing valve cylinder.   The slot between the hole and the top of the cylinder as well as the top of the hole are covered by the reversing valve cap.  
Valve Steam Passages: The steam enters via the port on the right side of the high pressure steam cylinder, travels up the side of the cylinder and into the horizontal steam passage in  the right side center of the head.  There is a vertical passage up the right side of the valve housing that intersects with the horizontal passage in the head.  A horizontal passage in the valve housing to the right of the reversing valve cylinder intersects with the vertical passage and provides steam to the center of the reversing valve. All the remaining passages are horizontal in the valve housing.  One passage runs back to front on the right end of the housing interesting the vertical passage.  This passage  intersects a passage that runs right to left in front of the reversing valve and  intersects a passage that runs back to front along the right side of the main valve cylinder.  There are intersecting passages on this back-to-front passage that carry the steam to the main valve cylinder. 
Valve Inter Cylinder Passages: The inter cylinder passages carry the steam that operates the main valve. One path travels horizontally right to left behind the reversing valve where it intersects a back to front path that goes into the reversing valve cylinder.  A second back to front passage is at an angle along the side of the main cylinder and also intersects the left to right passage.   This second back to front passage carries steam to the rear end of the main valve cylinder. 

There is a similar set of passages along the front of the valve housing that provide steam to the front of the main valve.  

Reversing Valve Piston:  The reversing valve piston will be turned from 3/8" brass rod.  Care should be taken to make the grooves as accurate as possible.  The piston threads onto the end of the valve rod.

Reversing Valve Cap: The cap is made from 3/4" square brass bar. The cap can be used as a template to drill and tap the four holes in the valve housing for the 2-56 mounting screws.

Main Valve Sleeve: The sleeve is turned from brass rod.  The OD will be adjusted so that it is a sliding fit in the valve housing.  The sleeve will be secured and sealed with Loctite 620.  All the grooves are initially cut 0.04" wide and used to align the steam holes into the cylinder.  The outside (steam input) grooves will be widened toward the ends after the holes are drilled through the sleeve.  At least six 0.04" diameter holes will be drilled in each groove.  The inside will be smoothed after the holes have been drilled.  The sleeve groove positions should be made as accurate as possible to insure proper valve operation.
Main Valve Piston: The main valve piston is similar to reversing valve piston but longer with five grooves for O-Rings. The piston will be turned from brass rod.  The O-Ring grooves should be turned as accurately as possible to insure proper valve operation.

It is convenient to tap each end 4-40 for a screw to manually operate the valve during testing.

Main Valve End Cover: The two end covers are fabricated of brass or bronze .  I'll probably turn the round part from 1.375" diameter rod and then square off the edges on the mill.   Two end covers are required.

The end covers can be used as  templates  to drill and tap the holes in the valve housing for the four #2-56 mounting screws. 

Upper Steam Head Large Alignment Washer: This washer is cut from brass or bronze rod.  The washer is attached with a couple 4-40 FH screws.  The screw holes will be into the thicker part of the head where there is room for 3/16" deep holes.

Upper Steam Head Small Alignment Washer This washer will probably be cut from brass or bronze rod stock.  This washer also retains the reversing rod seals.  The washer will be fastened to the head with a couple #4 FH screws into the thicker part of the head. .

Reversing Valve Rod: The rod will be made from 1/8" stainless steel rod stock.  A pair of 4-40 small pattern nuts will be tapped 5-40 and screwed on the  end of the valve rod that fits in the piston rod.  The nuts will be positioned  such that the valve rod has the correct amount of movement (0.156") when the piston moves between the two extreme positions.  The nuts are tightened against each other to lock them in position.   The valve piston is screwed onto the end threaded 4-40 and positioned properly and then held in place by a 4-40 lock nut.

At this point  the design is pretty well beat to death.  Guess it's time to make a few chips and see if it'll actually work.

 

 

 

Heisler Project
NLW Home